News

March 2011

The role of a Unilateral Notice in the protection of an equitable right

The recent case of Valais Ltd v Clydesdale Bank plc t/a Yorkshire Bank [2011] All ER (D) 87 confirmed that a unilateral notice is a means of protecting an equitable chargee’s ranking.  However, it will not impede a sale.

The Facts

• Valais Ltd was the first proprietor of a registered charge against four properties and had taken possession of the properties as the mortgagee in possession. 
• Clydesdale Bank plc t/a Yorkshire Bank (‘the Bank’) had entered unilateral notices against the titles to the four properties in order to protect the equitable charges it held over the properties. 
• Valais Ltd proposed to sell the properties at auction but the auctioneers advised that, in the current market, the presence of the unilateral notices would act as a deterrent to a prospective purchaser.
• As a result of this advice, Valais Ltd sought an interim order that the Bank remove the unilateral notices. 

The Issue

The central issue was whether the Bank’s unilateral notices should be removed to facilitate the sale of the properties. 

Valais Ltd submitted that the presence of the unilateral notices could hamper the sale of the properties as mortgagee in possession.  The Bank submitted that the unilateral notices were the only way it could ensure that a potential purchaser is notified of the Bank’s interest and that the perception that the existence of the unilateral notices could cause difficulty in selling the property was misplaced. 

The Decision

The Court held that the sale by Valais Ltd, as the first mortgagee in possession, would overreach the Bank’s interest pursuant to s.114(1) of the Law of Property Act 1925 (‘the 1925 Act’).  Thus Valais Ltd could sell free from the effect of the equitable charge. 

The Bank’s entitlement under section 105 of the 1925 Act is to payment of any surplus only after Valais Ltd had been repaid in full. 

Thus the unilateral notices would not impede the sale to purchasers who would take free of the Bank’s charge. 

Additionally, the Court held that the nature and reason for the unilateral notices would be clear to a potential buyer on the face of the Register.  Therefore there was no reason for the Court to override legal rights on the basis of a flawed market perception in the presence of a unilateral notice. 

Comment

This case was based upon a misconception of the protection afforded by a unilateral notice.  The case provides comfort for a purchaser who can be assured that they will take free of an equitable charge in analogous circumstances. 

Please note that this information is provided for general knowledge only and therefore specific advice should be sought for individual cases.

 

For further information please contact:

Glovers RSS

Latest News

News Search:
10 Feb 2016
Construction and Engineering Pre-Action Protocol – Please Don’t Go

Glovers was one of fifteen “Track 1” contributor ... >

01 Feb 2016
Residential Landlords’ Requirement to Check Immigration Status

From 1 February 2016, the right to rent requirements in ... >

06 Jan 2016
Deeds – Looking at the concept of “Signed, Sealed, Delivered” in 2016

The case of Re Armstrong Brands Ltd (In Administration) ... >

17 Dec 2015
Britain’s eating-out revolution

According to the December 2015 edition of the Market Growth ... >

10 Dec 2015
Restaurants and Permitted Development Rights Update

The decline in the viability of some pubs coupled with ... >

09 Dec 2015
Brexit: the potential impact on foreign restaurant employees if the UK leaves the EU

Following the recent election, the Prime Minister has ... >

08 Dec 2015
Break Clauses and Rent Refunds in Commercial Property Leases: Update

In a landmark decision the Supreme Court has recently ruled ... >

30 Nov 2015
News Update: Autumn Review 2015 – SDLT Changes

The Spending Review and Autumn Statement 2015 has outlined ... >

24 Nov 2015
The Potential Impact of the National Living Wage on the Hospitality Industry

As we all know, from 1 April 2016, employers will have ... >

10 Nov 2015
Rugby World Cup draws in shoppers

According to the latest research from the British Council ... >

<<12345...>>